the downward spiral vs the fragile

[droidspawn]

the fragile

[jawn galliano]

TDS by a mile

[droidspawn]

[rhino]

d.s. by a good bit, but i still love the fragile

[droidspawn]

[quote name="Dudley"]TDS by a mile [/quote]



do you not like the fragile at all?

[jawn galliano]

haven't really listened to it all that much

[Methuselah Honeysuckle]

[quote name="rhino"]d.s. by a good bit, but i still love the fragile[/quote]

[agony bagony]

fragile, no question

[droidspawn]

[Mesarthim]

I always felt like the fragile is when NIN peaked.

[Abzu]

[quote name="Dudley"]TDS by the size of the universe [/quote]

This shouldn't even be a question and I am disappointed in jorsh and two other voters in this period.



the downward spiral was the peak and the fragile was the last album really worth buying. (The Slip was alright and each album between had one or two okay songs and I still really respect Trent, but nothing on a par with the earlier material.)









Why is this thread even.

[agony bagony]

downward spiral has always bored me. i may give it another listen someday, but, eh

[Abzu]

The progression a warm place - eraser - reptile is one of the best song clusters ever assembled. I put it right up with the cluster on Formulas: Heaving Earth - Prayer of Hatred - Bil Ur-Sag - Nothing Is Not

[shadowalk]

[quote name="Nick"]
[quote name="rhino"]d.s. by a good bit, but i still love the fragile[/quote][/quote]

[deckard]

[quote name="it the dusto"]fragile, no question[/quote]

[droidspawn]